Amendment 16 — part 2

RC-B10-0173/2024 – § 5 – Am 16/2

Roll-call vote on 2024-11-28 · Rejected

Where this vote fits
Sitting
28 November 2024
Subject
Recommendation on smoke- and aerosol-free environments
This vote
Vote 10 of 50 on this subject — a vote on an amendment
This part
‘regrets that the lack of differentiation with regard to smoke-free environments gives the wrong signal, undermines the use of new and emerging products for those switching entirely away from cigarettes and perpetuates misconceptions about their relative risks, as the Commission was unable to support its proposal with conclusive scientific evidence regarding the impact of second-hand aerosols;’
Requested by
split vote: PPE · roll call: ECR

Amendments change the text; the final vote decides it. How plenary voting works

For 149 Against 403 Abstained 26

578 votes cast

By political group

GroupForAgainstAbstained
0340
0510
01100
0557
101252
51314
51111
2400
1092

Individual votes (578)

MemberCtryGroupVote
Abir AL-SAHLANI SE Abstained
Adam BIELAN PL For
Adina VĂLEAN RO Against
Adnan DIBRANI SE Against
Adrián VÁZQUEZ LÁZARA ES Against
Adrian-George AXINIA RO Abstained
Aleksandar NIKOLIC FR For
Alessandra MORETTI IT Against
Alessandro ZAN IT Against
Alex AGIUS SALIBA MT Against
Alexander JUNGBLUTH DE For
Alexander SELL DE For
Alexandr VONDRA CZ For
Alexandra GEESE DE Against
Alexandre VARAUT FR For
Alice KUHNKE SE Against
Alice TEODORESCU MÅWE SE Against
Alma EZCURRA ALMANSA ES Against
Ana Catarina MENDES PT Against
Ana Miguel PEDRO PT Against
Ana MIRANDA PAZ ES Against
Ana VASCONCELOS PT Abstained
András GYÜRK HU Against
András LÁSZLÓ HU Against
André ROUGÉ FR For
Andrea WECHSLER DE Against
Andreas GLÜCK DE Against
Andreas SCHWAB DE Against
Andrey KOVATCHEV BG Against
Andrey NOVAKOV BG Against
Andrzej BUŁA PL Against
Andrzej HALICKI PL Against
Angéline FURET FR For
Anja ARNDT DE For
Anna BRYŁKA PL For
Anna CAVAZZINI DE Against
Anna STROLENBERG NL Against
Anna ZALEWSKA PL For
Anna-Maja HENRIKSSON FI Against
Annalisa CORRADO IT Against
Annamária VICSEK HU Against
Anne-Sophie FRIGOUT FR For
Anouk VAN BRUG NL Against
Anthony SMITH FR Against
Antonella SBERNA IT For
Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITE ES Against
António TÂNGER CORRÊA PT For
Arash SAEIDI FR Against
Arba KOKALARI SE For
Arkadiusz MULARCZYK PL Abstained
Arno BAUSEMER DE For
Assita KANKO BE Abstained
Auke ZIJLSTRA NL For
Aura SALLA FI Against
Aurelijus VERYGA LT Against
Aurore LALUCQ FR Against
Axel VOSS DE Against
Barbara BONTE BE For
Bart GROOTHUIS NL Against
Bartłomiej SIENKIEWICZ PL Against
Bartosz ARŁUKOWICZ PL Against
Beata SZYDŁO PL For
Beatrice TIMGREN SE For
Benedetta SCUDERI IT Against
Benoit CASSART BE Against
Bernard GUETTA FR Against
Bernd LANGE DE Against
Bert-Jan RUISSEN NL Against
Biljana BORZAN HR Against
Billy KELLEHER IE Against
Bogdan Andrzej ZDROJEWSKI PL Against
Bogdan RZOŃCA PL For
Borja GIMÉNEZ LARRAZ ES Against
Borys BUDKA PL Against
Brando BENIFEI IT Against
Branko GRIMS SI For
Brigitte VAN DEN BERG NL Against
Bruno GONÇALVES PT Against
Bruno TOBBACK BE Against
Camilla LAURETI IT Against
Carla TAVARES PT Against
Carlo FIDANZA IT For
Carmen CRESPO DÍAZ ES Against
Carolina MORACE IT Against
Catarina MARTINS PT Against
Catarina VIEIRA NL Against
Catherine GRISET FR For
Cecilia STRADA IT Against
Céline IMART FR Against
César LUENA ES Against
Charles GOERENS LU Against
Chiara GEMMA IT For
Christian DOLESCHAL DE Against
Christian EHLER DE Against
Christine ANDERSON DE For
Christophe BAY FR For
Christophe CLERGEAU FR Against
Christophe GOMART FR Against
Christophe GRUDLER FR Against
Claire FITA FR Against
Claudiu-Richard TÂRZIU RO For
Cristina MAESTRE ES Against
Csaba DÖMÖTÖR HU Against
Cynthia NÍ MHURCHÚ IE Against
Dainius ŽALIMAS LT Against
Damian BOESELAGER DE Against
Damien CARÊME FR Against
Dan BARNA RO Against
Daniel ATTARD MT Against
Daniel BUDA RO Against
Daniel FREUND DE Against
Daniel OBAJTEK PL For
Daniele POLATO IT For
Danilo DELLA VALLE IT Against
Danuše NERUDOVÁ CZ Against
Dario TAMBURRANO IT Against
Dariusz JOŃSKI PL Against
David CASA MT Against
David CORMAND FR Against
David MCALLISTER DE Against
New here? How plenary voting works and how to read this page

A sitting is one day of voting in the Parliament’s plenary. Everything voted that day is listed here by subject — a report, resolution, agreement or objection the Parliament is deciding on. Subjects are sorted into sections by what kind of decision they are (new laws, international agreements, non-binding resolutions, …); each section explains what “adopted” means there.

Each subject can involve many ballots. MEPs first vote on amendments (proposed changes) and on parts of the text a group asked to vote on separately, then hold the decisive vote on the whole text — that is the result shown at the top of every subject. The strip of squares and circles under it shows all the ballots in the order they were taken; open the list to see each one.

Only roll-call votes record how each MEP voted — click one to see every individual position and the full breakdown by political group. The row of group badges (✓ mostly for, ✗ mostly against, – mostly abstained, ~ split) shows which groups backed a result. Votes by show of hands record only the outcome.

Every subject is based on a document (a committee report, a motion for a resolution, or a Council/Commission text) and belongs to a procedure — the full legislative file that can span years. The buttons on each subject take you to both.

Glossary: Am 27 = amendment 27 · § 5 = paragraph 5 · part 1/2 = a paragraph or amendment voted in separate parts (a split vote) · separate vote = a paragraph voted on its own, usually so a group can vote against it · = joins identical amendments voted together · 1st reading (***I) = Parliament’s first pass at a proposed law · Lapsed = fell away without a vote because an earlier vote settled the matter.