← Sitting 2024-03-12

A9-0047/2024 – Isabel García Muñoz – Article 1, § 1, point 4; Directive 96/53/EC; Article 4 b – Am 58D= 65D=

Article 1, § 1, point 4 Directive 96/53/EC; Article 4 b · Roll-call vote on 2024-03-12 · Rejected

For 261 Against 338 Abstained 16

By political group

GroupForAgainstAbstained
1200
2800
19440
16200
7801
9140
1484
310
222
Former/unknown1511699

Individual votes (615)

MemberCountryGroupVote
Abir AL-SAHLANISweden Against
Adam JARUBASPoland Against
Adrián VÁZQUEZ LÁZARASpain Against
Alessandra MORETTIItaly For
Alexander BERNHUBERAustria Against
Alexandra GEESEGermany For
Alice KUHNKESweden For
Alicia HOMS GINELSpain Against
Ana MIRANDA PAZSpain For
András GYÜRKHungary Abstained
André ROUGÉFrance For
Andreas GLÜCKGermany Against
Andreas SCHIEDERAustria For
Andreas SCHWABGermany Against
Andrey KOVATCHEVBulgaria Against
Andrey NOVAKOVBulgaria Against
Andrzej HALICKIPoland Against
Angelika NIEBLERGermany Against
Angelika WINZIGAustria For
Anja HAZEKAMPNetherlands For
Anna CAVAZZINIGermany For
Anna ZALEWSKAPoland For
Antonio LÓPEZ-ISTÚRIZ WHITESpain Against
Arba KOKALARISweden Against
Assita KANKOBelgium Against
Aurore LALUCQFrance For
Axel VOSSGermany Against
Barry ANDREWSIreland Against
Bart GROOTHUISNetherlands Against
Beata SZYDŁOPoland For
Bernard GUETTAFrance For
Bernd LANGEGermany Against
Bert-Jan RUISSENNetherlands Against
Biljana BORZANCroatia Against
Billy KELLEHERIreland Against
Birgit SIPPELGermany For
Bogdan RZOŃCAPoland For
Brando BENIFEIItaly Against
Camilla LAURETIItaly For
Carlo FIDANZAItaly Against
Caterina CHINNICIItaly Against
Catherine GRISETFrance For
César LUENASpain Against
Charles GOERENSLuxembourg For
Charlie WEIMERSSweden Against
Chiara GEMMAItaly Against
Christel SCHALDEMOSEDenmark Against
Christian DOLESCHALGermany Against
Christian EHLERGermany Against
Christine ANDERSONGermany For
Christophe CLERGEAUFrance For
Christophe GRUDLERFrance For
Cristian TERHEŞRomania Against
Cristina MAESTRESpain Against
Csaba MOLNÁRHungary For
Damian BOESELAGERGermany For
Damien CARÊMEFrance For
Dan NICARomania Against
Daniel BUDARomania Against
Daniel FREUNDGermany For
David CASAMalta Against
David CORMANDFrance For
David MCALLISTERGermany Against
Delara BURKHARDTGermany For
Denis NESCIItaly Against
Dennis RADTKEGermany Against
Diana RIBA I GINERSpain For
Dolors MONTSERRATSpain Against
Dominik TARCZYŃSKIPoland For
Dragoş BENEARomania Against
Eero HEINÄLUOMAFinland Against
Elisabetta GUALMINIItaly Against
Elissavet VOZEMBERG-VRIONIDIGreece Against
Elżbieta Katarzyna ŁUKACIJEWSKAPoland Against
Emil RADEVBulgaria Against
Emma WIESNERSweden Against
Emmanouil FRAGKOSGreece Against
Emmanouil KEFALOGIANNISGreece Against
Engin EROGLUGermany Against
Enikő GYŐRIHungary Abstained
Erik MARQUARDTGermany For
Ernő SCHALLER-BAROSSHungary Abstained
Eva MAYDELLBulgaria Against
Evelyn REGNERAustria For
Evin INCIRSweden Against
Ewa KOPACZPoland Against
Fabienne KELLERFrance For
Former MEP #114268Against
Former MEP #118949Against
Former MEP #120478For
Former MEP #124586Abstained
Former MEP #124692Against
Former MEP #124693For
Former MEP #124696Against
Former MEP #124704Against
Former MEP #124708Against
Former MEP #124710Against
Former MEP #124712Abstained
Former MEP #124714Abstained
Former MEP #124726Against
Former MEP #124734Against
Former MEP #124735Against
Former MEP #124738For
Former MEP #124739Against
Former MEP #124747Against
Former MEP #124771For
Former MEP #124777For
Former MEP #124780Against
Former MEP #124781Against
Former MEP #124812For
Former MEP #124821Against
Former MEP #124822For
Former MEP #124831Against
Former MEP #124833For
Former MEP #124835For
Former MEP #124837For
Former MEP #124844For
Former MEP #124852Against
Former MEP #124856For
Former MEP #124872Against
Former MEP #124873Against
Former MEP #124875For
Former MEP #124891For
Former MEP #124929Against
Former MEP #124934For
Former MEP #124936For
Former MEP #124988Against
Former MEP #124992For
Former MEP #124996Against
Former MEP #125004Against
Former MEP #125005Against
Former MEP #125020Against
Former MEP #125021Against
Former MEP #125025For
Former MEP #125030Against
Former MEP #125038Against
Former MEP #125043Against
Former MEP #125045Against
Former MEP #125063Against
Former MEP #125067Against
Former MEP #125109Against
Former MEP #125128Against
Former MEP #125214For
Former MEP #125237Against
Former MEP #125706Against
Former MEP #126644Against
Former MEP #127096Against
Former MEP #129164Against
Former MEP #130256Against
Former MEP #130833For
Former MEP #131507For
Former MEP #132191For
Former MEP #132366Against
Former MEP #136236For
Former MEP #182995For
Former MEP #183793Against
Former MEP #185974For
Former MEP #1892Against
Former MEP #189525Against
Former MEP #190518Against
Former MEP #190519Against
Former MEP #190774For
Former MEP #193273For
Former MEP #197390Against
Former MEP #197418Against
Former MEP #197419Against
Former MEP #197422Against
Former MEP #197423For
Former MEP #197427Against
Former MEP #197431For
Former MEP #197438Against
Former MEP #197441Against
Former MEP #197446Against
Former MEP #197451For
Former MEP #197452For
Former MEP #197453For
Former MEP #197455Against
Former MEP #197458For
Former MEP #197459For
Former MEP #197465For
Former MEP #197467Against
Former MEP #197472For
Former MEP #197478Against
Former MEP #197480For
Former MEP #197481For
Former MEP #197482For
Former MEP #197483For
Former MEP #197488For
Former MEP #197489For
Former MEP #197495For
Former MEP #197502For
Former MEP #197505For
Former MEP #197506For
Former MEP #197507Against
Former MEP #197510Against
Former MEP #197511For
Former MEP #197512For
Former MEP #197513Against
Former MEP #197515Against
Former MEP #197518For
Former MEP #197519For
Former MEP #197520For
Former MEP #197522Against
Former MEP #197526Against
Former MEP #197527For
Former MEP #197530For
Former MEP #197531For
Former MEP #197532Abstained
Former MEP #197536For
Former MEP #197538For
Former MEP #197539For
Former MEP #197540Against
Former MEP #197541For
Former MEP #197544For
Former MEP #197546For
Former MEP #197547For
Former MEP #197550For
Former MEP #197551For
Former MEP #197559For
Former MEP #197563Against
Former MEP #197564Against
Former MEP #197566For
Former MEP #197567For
Former MEP #197571For
Former MEP #197576For
Former MEP #197582Against
Former MEP #197584For
Former MEP #197585For
Former MEP #197586Against
Former MEP #197587Against
Former MEP #197588For
Former MEP #197595For
Former MEP #197596Against
Former MEP #197608Against
Former MEP #197610Against
Former MEP #197611Against
Former MEP #197619For
Former MEP #197629For
Former MEP #197632For
Former MEP #197634Against
Former MEP #197635Against
Former MEP #197637Against
Former MEP #197638Against
Former MEP #197641Against
Former MEP #197645For
Former MEP #197650Against
Former MEP #197654For
Former MEP #197657Against
Former MEP #197665Against
Former MEP #197668Against
Former MEP #197671Against
Former MEP #197680For
Former MEP #197695Against
Former MEP #197698For
Former MEP #197709Against
Former MEP #197717Against
Former MEP #197720Against
Former MEP #197728Against
Former MEP #197731For
Former MEP #197740Abstained
Former MEP #197742Against
Former MEP #197743For
Former MEP #197754For
Former MEP #197756Against
Former MEP #197764Against
Former MEP #197765Against
Former MEP #197766For
Former MEP #197767Against
Former MEP #197771Against
Former MEP #197776Against
Former MEP #197777Against
Former MEP #197778Against
Former MEP #197783Against
Former MEP #197785For
Former MEP #197787Against
Former MEP #197788Against
Former MEP #197791For
Former MEP #197792For
Former MEP #197798Against
Former MEP #197801For
Former MEP #197804For
Former MEP #197806Against
Former MEP #197808For
Former MEP #197817For
Former MEP #197826Against
Former MEP #197827For
Former MEP #197835Against
Former MEP #197836Against
Former MEP #197837For
Former MEP #197838Against
Former MEP #197843Against
Former MEP #197844Against
Former MEP #197846Against
Former MEP #197848Against
Former MEP #197849Against
Former MEP #197889For
Former MEP #197894Abstained
Former MEP #197935Abstained
Former MEP #198063Against
Former MEP #198096Against
Former MEP #198329Against
Former MEP #1992Against
Former MEP #199996Against
Former MEP #202351For
Former MEP #204334Against
Former MEP #204335For
Former MEP #204368For
Former MEP #204416For
Former MEP #204420For
Former MEP #204421For
Former MEP #204443For
Former MEP #204733For
Former MEP #205452For
Former MEP #209091Against
Former MEP #209140Against
Former MEP #209896Against
Former MEP #212855Against
Former MEP #218349Against
Former MEP #221463Against
Former MEP #226260Against
Former MEP #228604Against
Former MEP #229519Against
Former MEP #2323Against
Former MEP #234344For
Former MEP #236051For
Former MEP #236052For
Former MEP #23712Against
Former MEP #237224Against
Former MEP #237320Against
Former MEP #23768Against
Former MEP #237779Against
Former MEP #238639Against
Former MEP #238674For
Former MEP #239255Against
Former MEP #239256Against
Former MEP #239257For
Former MEP #239258For
Former MEP #239262Against
Former MEP #239972Against
Former MEP #240478For
Former MEP #243912Against
Former MEP #243979Against
Former MEP #24505For
Former MEP #245858For
Former MEP #24594For
Former MEP #247122For
Former MEP #247709Against
Former MEP #247737Against
Former MEP #249284For
Former MEP #249285For
Former MEP #249443For
Former MEP #249826For
Former MEP #250235Against
Former MEP #250237Against
Former MEP #250538For
Former MEP #250572For
Former MEP #250918For
Former MEP #251249For
Former MEP #251268Against
Former MEP #251859For
Former MEP #253008Against
Former MEP #253043Against
Former MEP #27714Abstained
Former MEP #28141Abstained
Former MEP #28161For
Former MEP #28219Against
Former MEP #28266For
Former MEP #28288Against
Former MEP #28294Against
Former MEP #28297For
Former MEP #28340For
Former MEP #28346For
Former MEP #28353For
Former MEP #28372For
Former MEP #28429Against
Former MEP #28586For
Former MEP #28619For
Former MEP #29579Against
Former MEP #33982Against
Former MEP #33997Against
Former MEP #34578Against
Former MEP #35016Against
Former MEP #38420Against
Former MEP #38595Against
Former MEP #4246For
Former MEP #4344Against
Former MEP #4560Against
Former MEP #5565For
Former MEP #58789Against
Former MEP #88715For
Former MEP #96646For
Former MEP #96648For
Former MEP #96713Against
Former MEP #96725For
Former MEP #96734For
Former MEP #96739For
Former MEP #96747For
Former MEP #96750For
Former MEP #96771Against
Former MEP #96772Against
Former MEP #96776For
Former MEP #96779Against
Former MEP #96796For
Former MEP #96801For
Former MEP #96820For
Former MEP #96837For
Former MEP #96852For
Former MEP #96867Against
Former MEP #96868For
Former MEP #96880For
Former MEP #96885For
Former MEP #96891Against
Former MEP #96899Against
Former MEP #96952For
Former MEP #96991Against
Former MEP #99283Against
France JAMETFrance For
Francisco José MILLÁN MONSpain Against
François-Xavier BELLAMYFrance For
Gabriel MATOSpain Against
Gabriele BISCHOFFGermany Against
Georg MAYERAustria For
Gerolf ANNEMANSBelgium For
Gilles BOYERFrance For
Giuseppe MILAZZOItaly Against
Günther SIDLAustria Against
György HÖLVÉNYIHungary Against
Hannah NEUMANNGermany For
Hannes HEIDEAustria For
Harald VILIMSKYAustria For
Heléne FRITZONSweden Against
Herbert DORFMANNItaly For
Hilde VAUTMANSBelgium Against
Ilhan KYUCHYUKBulgaria Against
Inese VAIDERELatvia Against
Iratxe GARCÍA PÉREZSpain Against
Irena JOVEVASlovenia For
Irene TINAGLIItaly For
Isabel BENJUMEA BENJUMEASpain Against
Isabella TOVAGLIERIItaly Against
Iuliu WINKLERRomania Against
Ivan DAVIDCzechia For
Ivars IJABSLatvia Against
Jaak MADISONEstonia Against
Jadwiga WIŚNIEWSKAPoland For
Jan-Christoph OETJENGermany Against
Jana TOOMEstonia Against
Janusz LEWANDOWSKIPoland Against
Javi LÓPEZSpain Against
Javier MORENO SÁNCHEZSpain Against
Javier ZARZALEJOSSpain Against
Jean-Paul GARRAUDFrance For
Jens GEIERGermany Against
Jens GIESEKEGermany Against
Jérémy DECERLEFrance For
Jeroen LENAERSNetherlands Against
Jessica POLFJÄRDSweden Against
Joachim Stanisław BRUDZIŃSKIPoland For
Johan VAN OVERTVELDTBelgium Against
Jonás FERNÁNDEZSpain Against
Jordan BARDELLAFrance For
Jorge BUXADÉ VILLALBASpain Against
Jörgen WARBORNSweden Against
Juan Fernando LÓPEZ AGUILARSpain Against
Juan Ignacio ZOIDO ÁLVAREZSpain Against
Jutta PAULUSGermany For
Karin KARLSBROSweden Against
Karlo RESSLERCroatia Against
Katarina BARLEYGermany For
Katarína ROTH NEVEĎALOVÁSlovakia Against
Kateřina KONEČNÁCzechia For
Kathleen VAN BREMPTBelgium Against
Katrin LANGENSIEPENGermany For
Kim VAN SPARRENTAKNetherlands For
Kinga GÁLHungary Abstained
Klára DOBREVHungary For
Konstantinos ARVANITISGreece For
Kosma ZŁOTOWSKIPoland For
Kostas PAPADAKISGreece Abstained
Lara WOLTERSNetherlands Against
Laura BALLARÍN CEREZASpain Against
Laurence FARRENGFrance For
Lefteris NIKOLAOU-ALAVANOSGreece Abstained
Leila CHAIBIFrance For
Lena DÜPONTGermany Against
Lídia PEREIRAPortugal Against
Lina GÁLVEZSpain Against
Liudas MAŽYLISLithuania Against
Loránt VINCZERomania Against
Luděk NIEDERMAYERCzechia Against
Lukas MANDLAustria For
Łukasz KOHUTPoland Against
Luke Ming FLANAGANIreland For
Magdalena ADAMOWICZPoland Against
Malik AZMANINetherlands Against
Manfred WEBERGermany Against
Manon AUBRYFrance For
Manuela RIPAGermany For
Marc ANGELLuxembourg For
Marc BOTENGABelgium For
Marcos ROS SEMPERESpain Against
Margarita DE LA PISA CARRIÓNSpain Against
Maria GRAPINIRomania Against
Maria NOICHLGermany For
Maria WALSHIreland Against
Marianne VINDDenmark Against
Marie TOUSSAINTFrance For
Marina KALJURANDEstonia Against
Marina MESUREFrance For
Mario FUROREItaly For
Marion WALSMANNGermany Against
Markéta GREGOROVÁCzechia For
Markus BUCHHEITGermany For
Markus FERBERGermany Against
Martin HÄUSLINGGermany For
Martin HOJSÍKSlovakia For
Martin SCHIRDEWANGermany For
Martin SONNEBORNGermany For
Martine KEMPLuxembourg Abstained
Massimiliano SALINIItaly Against
Mathilde ANDROUËTFrance For
Matjaž NEMECSlovenia Against
Matthias ECKEGermany For
Michael BLOSSGermany For
Michael GAHLERGermany Against
Michal WIEZIKSlovakia For
Mihai TUDOSERomania Against
Milan UHRÍKSlovakia Against
Milan ZVERSlovenia Against
Mircea-Gheorghe HAVARomania Against
Miriam LEXMANNSlovakia Against
Mohammed CHAHIMNetherlands Against
Monika BEŇOVÁSlovakia Against
Monika HOHLMEIERGermany Against
Moritz KÖRNERGermany Against
Morten LØKKEGAARDDenmark Against
Mounir SATOURIFrance For
Nacho SÁNCHEZ AMORSpain Against
Nadine MORANOFrance For
Nathalie LOISEAUFrance For
Niclas HERBSTGermany Against
Nicola PROCACCINIItaly Against
Nicolas BAYFrance For
Nicolás GONZÁLEZ CASARESSpain Against
Niels FUGLSANGDenmark Against
Niels GEUKINGGermany Against
Nikos PAPANDREOUGreece Against
Nils UŠAKOVSLatvia Against
Nora MEBAREKFrance For
Norbert LINSGermany Against
Olivier CHASTELBelgium Against
Ondřej KNOTEKCzechia Against
Özlem DEMIRELGermany For
Pablo ARIAS ECHEVERRÍASpain Against
Pär HOLMGRENSweden For
Pascal ARIMONTBelgium Against
Pascal CANFINFrance For
Patryk JAKIPoland For
Peter LIESEGermany Against
Petras AUŠTREVIČIUSLithuania For
Philippe OLIVIERFrance For
Pietro FIOCCHIItaly Against
Pilar DEL CASTILLO VERASpain Against
Radan KANEVBulgaria Against
Raffaele STANCANELLIItaly Against
Ralf SEEKATZGermany Against
Rasmus ANDRESENGermany For
René REPASIGermany For
Riho TERRASEstonia Against
Robert BIEDROŃPoland For
Roman HAIDERAustria For
Romana JERKOVIĆCroatia Against
Romana TOMCSlovenia Against
Rosa ESTARÀS FERRAGUTSpain Against
Sabine VERHEYENGermany Against
Salvatore DE MEOItaly Against
Sandra KALNIETELatvia Against
Sandro GOZIFrance For
Sara MATTHIEUBelgium For
Saskia BRICMONTBelgium For
Seán KELLYIreland Against
Sergey LAGODINSKYGermany For
Sergio BERLATOItaly Against
Siegfried MUREŞANRomania Against
Silvia SARDONEItaly Against
Sirpa PIETIKÄINENFinland For
Stéphanie YON-COURTINFrance For
Sunčana GLAVAKCroatia Against
Susana SOLÍS PÉREZSpain Against
Susanna CECCARDIItaly Against
Sven MIKSEREstonia Against
Sven SIMONGermany Against
Svenja HAHNGermany Against
Terry REINTKEGermany For
Thierry MARIANIFrance For
Thijs REUTENNetherlands Against
Thomas WAITZAustria For
Tiemo WÖLKENGermany Against
Tilly METZLuxembourg For
Tineke STRIKNetherlands For
Tom VANDENDRIESSCHEBelgium For
Tomas TOBÉSweden Against
Tomáš ZDECHOVSKÝCzechia Against
Tomislav SOKOLCroatia Against
Tonino PICULACroatia Against
Tsvetelina PENKOVABulgaria Against
Urmas PAETEstonia Against
Valérie HAYERFrance For
Vangelis MEIMARAKISGreece Against
Victor NEGRESCURomania Against
Vilija BLINKEVIČIŪTĖLithuania Against
Ville NIINISTÖFinland For
Virginie JORONFrance For
Younous OMARJEEFrance For
Željana ZOVKOCroatia Against